Skip to main content
New search
Property Audit ReportBBL 5000430021Generated Jun 11, 2026
Warning — Significant Risk

Open Violations

1

DOB + HPD

Unpaid Fines

$15k

OATH / ECB

Flood Zone

X

FEMA designation

Audit Score

26/100

Composite index

Address-level public record preview

228 Benziger Avenue is tracked in NYC Property Audit as BBL 5000430021, located in SI, built in 1920, 3 residential units, 1 open DOB/HPD violation signals, $15,125 in unpaid OATH fines, FEMA flood zone X. The free preview keeps address-level facts crawl-visible while the full due-diligence report remains available in the audit.

Unlock the full 13-page report — $9.99
Free previewPro unlocks: owner of record · mortgage details · fine amounts · permit costs · school ratings · neighborhood demographics Unlock full report

Free preview · 2 pages

Unlock the full PDF

All findings, all sources, one defensible document.

Download Full Property Report

One-time payment · $9.99 · Secure Stripe checkout

Key Findings

2 items
1 open violation on record· DOB · HPD
Annual property tax estimated at ~$5,918 (Tax Class 2)· NYC DOF

Building Details

✓ Verified · PLUTO
Building Area
2,571 sf
Zoning
R3A
Basement
Partial Basement
Land Use
Multi-Family Walk-Up Buildings
Registered Owner
Quick facts
How many units does this building have?
3 residential units.
How tall is this building?
2.5 stories, non-fireproof construction, built in 1920.
How big is the lot?
2,500 sq ft (25 ft × 100 ft).
What's the building class?
Class C0 — Walk-up apt.
How many buildings are on this lot?
1 building on the lot.
Overall Outlook
Long-term signal for residential or commercial viability
Caution — Known Issues
Maintenance Reliability
Minor open violations — review details
67 / 100
Safety
Elevated activity — consider before signing
26 / 100
Daily Life
Transit access via Tompkinsville (SIR)
~12 min subway

Compliance · 10-year history

Violation timeline

DOB · HPD · OATH
201620182020202220242026
Active1Resolved with debt2Resolved2Hover any dot for detail

Violations & maintenance history

HPD · DOB · OATH1 open, 33 resolved

Open Issues — 1
Critical
(c) 27-2142(a) HMC: the following dwelling units were reoccupied while being subject to an order to repair/vacate order issued by the department; order conditions observed existing.
Apt 1 · 1st floor · 1st apartment from east at south
HPD · Filed Aug 2024 · Open ·
Resolved History — 33 (showing 3)
Closed
Failure to comply with the commissioner's order to file a certificate of correction with the department of buildings. Certificate of correction not on file with DOB for class 1 vio issued on 8/13/24 for disobey
OATH · Filed Feb 2025 · Closed
Closed
Failure to obey a vacate order from the commissioner per 28-207.4. Full vacate order #s45/16 exists on the property, issued on 8/18/2016 not in compliance. At time of inspection, observed 1 female with 4 childr
OATH · Filed Aug 2024 · Closed
Closed
, § 302 mdl : apartments have been issued a commissioner's order and occupants are in need of relocation services. Apartments cannot be re-occupied unitl the commissioner's order is revoked after HPD inspection of apartments. Commissioner's order# 16/0116
§ 27-2091 HMCApt 1 · 1st floor
HPD · Filed Dec 2016 · Closed ·

Other properties in the area with active violation history — useful comparables when evaluating risk.

Browse all Staten Island buildings in our index →